‘A world of crashing cultural plates’

Two posts on languages, religion and identities. Razib foresees more intense conflict, in a globalizing world, among civilizations:

Though language is emotionally salient for many, that is really not what I had in mind. In The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order Samuel Huntington presented a thesis which used religion as the major organizing principle around which societies cohere. I am willing to accept this more or less (though language is obviously a major fissure as well). I have argued before that communication improvements are a major reason that I believe Islam is becoming more centralized in terms of belief and practice; the ummah is realizing its unity much more concretely than in the past. Recently I was reading a history of Burma, and the author noted that in the past many Muslims who were in areas where they were a minority were difficult to distinguish from non-Muslims. Most of their practices were similar to their neighbors, and they did not dress any differently, men and women prayed in a mixed setting etc. Much the same could be said of 19th century Bengal, where the outlook of Muslim and Hindu peasants didn’t differ greatly and veneration of Hindu and Sufi saints bled into each other…

Neelakantan also foresees more conflict in India arising from the dilution of ‘national’ diversity in language and religion:

You might say, so what? It is the denial of the national identity, the heritage, which to date has been an identity to stand by, that is disturbing. The national identity of India closely identified with its linguistic identity and heritage irrespective of religion is being attempted to be superimposed by a “superior ” identity, that of religion, that wants people to deny their heritage and accept a new one.

Religion, until recently here has always found its way in India through its heritage. Kerala Christians and Kashmiri Muslims are an example Religions have modified their presence in India, much like McDonalds customized its Aloo Tikki and it is this customization that is in danger. The India that has been held together by strands of language and customs that cut across religion suddenly finds itself being cut apart by the scissor of religion. Make no mistake. This is a trend that will have far reaching implications. This may be a little premature, but the signs are clear.

Linked by kuffir. Join Blogbharti facebook group.

0 Responses to “‘A world of crashing cultural plates’”


  1. No Comments

Leave a Reply

Enter the two words with a space in between




Featured article

Hearing the voices

Did you know that 87% of all links that Blogbharti linked to in it's first year were new? Did you know that in the 2,376 posts we did, we provided you with 3,087 links individual links excluding self-links and links to technorati and del.icio.us? Read more here.

 

May 2008
M T W T F S S
« Apr    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Get Blogbharti Content

Important note: The site feed urls have changed. Please update your feed reader with these feed urls

Site Feed
Comments Feed

Contact us:

Email us at contact [at] blogbharti.com

Active Discussions

  • Ankush (2)
  • Mridula (2)
  • abhishek (1)
  • amit's voice (1)
  • Anita (1)
  • Jayaprakash (1)
  • katrina kapoor (1)
  • Madhu Rao (1)
  • Naresh Kadyan (1)
  • Nikhil Narayanan (1)
  • Rakesh (1)
  • Ramesh Chandra (1)
  • Rima (1)
  • sphurthy (1)
  • Subhash Changarath (1)
  • Sunil (1)
  • swati (1)
  • V K Shridhar (1)
  • Vasanth (1)
  • Vinayak Parkhe (1)
  • Vinod Khare (1)
  • wawa (1)
  • Yoh (1)